avery
Wetware Developer
My acquisition of the domain hakr.io, which I will be moving this website to probably in January.
My domain requirements
- short, ideally <8 characters (including tld, excluding .)
- must be speakable over the phone
- preferably .io TLD, because I use the name Io, it’s short, it’s techy, moons and cows are cool
I thought about domains1 occasionally for over a year. quatl.ooo is a fun if obscure Star Trek reference I quickly snatched to just have a domain, but what if I got myself something nice? Maybe more professional? Obviously, good domains tend to be taken, so finding them coincidentally unclaimed after decades is rare, and you’re better off just getting weird or technical about your naming scheme2. What if there existed a place where you could cheaply buy domains that other people already purchased?
Expired Domains Dot Net
Periodically fetch all zone files3, diff them for when a site drops4, and whois those and stuff them into a db. When they pop up again in a zone file, remove from db. Make db maximally searchable for techies, and stick some referral links in there, maybe an ad bar. Fantastic website.
I forlornly cruised .io for a year. hakr.io came into my life about a month and a half ago, and I knew I had to make my move. Maybe I’m not doing security research, but I co-founded a successful hackspace <3
Categorically, it falls into the pool of 4-letter slop that tends to go for renewal price plus about $205, so automated competition would at most consist of some AI domain appraiser and purchaser. Would you build that?
Domain Expiration Ecosystem
Firstly, let’s define the roles.
- Registry: the TLD owner/manager, e.g. Verisign for
.com - Registrar: a customer-facing (ICANN-accredited) retail site for managing domains, e.g. Porkbun
- Registrant: the customer, e.g. me
Every registry has a different policy for their TLD(s). Generally, they all follow the same pattern6 after the expiration date passes without payment:
- Auto-Renew Grace Period. 0-45 days, usually 30 days. Registrar nags registrant, lets registrant re-pay.
- Toward the end of this period, registrars will typically break DNS records to get user attention. Often they will charge a fee7
- Registrars will often auction domains publicly for a few days before the next step
- Deletion from registry zone file occurs, breaking DNS, getting on
expireddomains.net, etc. - Redemption Grace Period. 30 days. Registrant has exclusive re-purchasing rights, with an additional redemption fee.
- Pending Delete. 5 days. Purely clerical; registrant loses exclusivity
- Release. General availability, etc.
Simple, right?
The Identity Digital DropZone Service
After pendingDelete, one would expect a domain to be deleted. However, if one were to check whois afterward, one would be greeted with this message:
This domain is currently available for application via the Identity Digital DropZone Service.
Identity Digital (formerly Donuts) owns 271 gTLDs at the time of writing; 42% of all gTLDs. They also provide service to many ccTLDs, including .io. Healthy market behavior.
DropZone exists for registrars, so us whoising peasants are left to discover the official DropZone website. As far as I can tell: instead of releasing a domain after deletion, ID holds the domain for an unspecified amount of time8 in DropZone to sell directly to registrars9 at additional cost. Retail backorder registrars generally avoid it10, instead opting to snipe the domain on public release.
So, a special, irrelevant hidden step between 4 and 5. We may now enter the seventh circle:
The Domain Backordering Metagame
Each registry typically batch-releases domains on some cadence11 as first-come-first-serve. How do you become first? Well, registrars have direct connections to registries that we don’t. Thankfully, many registrars offer backordering: they’ll competitively spam domain CREATE requests for you in the milliseconds after batch release. Predictably, this incentivizes an arms-race to DDoS registry servers, so registries cap inbound EPP connections per-registrar.
Registrars can get around this cap by…creating more registrars. ICANN must accredit these, so that’s money for ICANN, a moat for the registrars, and an artificially inflated cost for inbound registry server connections.
Registrants (that’s you and me) who want a domain must then create accounts with verified payment methods12 for each of the major backordering registrars13 for best odds.
Once one of the registrars wins a domain CREATE request, if multiple users backordered (for ~$60-on-success) the same domain, those users14 bid for the domain.
All for naught
Dynadot got it for me for $65, and nobody else ran the backorder gauntlet. I feel like it cost a lot more.
The list of available domains I considered but ultimately didn’t buy:
chan.cy,cute.tg,proxy.fan,grep.ps,auwx.ps↩︎If I didn’t get this domain I was going to buy
av3.io↩︎You don’t even have to do it yourself, there are cheap services for that ↩︎
This is a little fuzzy, given the expiration stages detailed below. This will catch domains after the Auto Renew Grace Period, but I believe expireddomains is also grabbing feeds from registries and other sites that do include some ARGP domains. ↩︎
For
.iospecifically. For.com, those are usually a few hundred to start. ↩︎ICANN has an Expired Registration Recovery Policy, but it doesn’t cover ccTLDs (the two-character country-code domains) ↩︎
Not ICANN-related. Some may refer to this practice as “holding your domain hostage” or “extortion”. ↩︎
Dynadot was convinced my domain was going to leave DropZone 2 weeks before it actually did, and invalidated my backorder request when it didn’t. I had to resubmit it a week later. DropCatch refused to consider a backorder for my domain, because it thought my domain wasn’t going to expire within the week (it did). ↩︎
And also apparently its own employees? That’s what the login portal seems to indicate. Anyway, I’ve read that it’s a dutch auction until the release date, but no cited sources. ↩︎
As far as I can tell. Dynadot has a higher pricing tier option for Afilias (bought by ID) TLDs; presumably passing on the DropZone fee. Either the fee is too high or the backordering registrar oligopsony (fostered by the ICANN accreditation entry-barriers discussed in the next section) largely ignores it. DropCatch’s parent company did (unsuccessfully) write to ICANN objecting to DropZone citing antitrust. ↩︎
For
.io, this is hourly ↩︎They want photos of your face and ID, by the way. Lots of fraud here, apparently ↩︎
dynadot, sav, dropcatch, namejet+snapnames (newfold digital), godaddy, pool. Did I get them all? ↩︎
DropCatch seems to just send the domain to public auction. Great service. ↩︎